Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Difference between Scholasticism and Empiricism

In his essay, “The Will to Believe”, the 20th century Harvard philosopher William James said the following:

“Our great difference from the Scholastic lies in the direction we face. The strength of his system lies in the principles, the origin, the terminus a quo of his thought; for us the strength is in the outcome, the upshot, the terminus ad quem.”

William James
“The Will to Believe”

I believe this expresses perfectly ny feelings about Catholic faith, Scholastic theology and modern science.

I am more confident in the source of my Catholic faith than in the results of my personal observation. I am more confident in the conclusions of Doctors of the Church than in those of modern scientists. This is exactly why I prefer to be a Scholastic than an Empiricist. This is why I will always trust the Scriptures and the Church and doubt the scientists who contradict them.

I would rather die doubting the observations of men and trusting in the authority of God. Interestingly, James argues in his essay that we are perfectly free to do so.

WCM

Be First to Comment

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *